Exception Handling Fishbone Diagram

This post originally appeared on Dr. Koopman’s Better Embedded System Software Blog. Reprinted with permission.

Exception handling is the soft underbelly of many software systems. A common observation is that there a lot more ways for things to go wrong than there are for them to go right, so designing and testing for exceptional conditions is difficult to do well. Anecdotally, it is also where you find many bugs that, while infrequently encountered, can cause dramatic system failures. While not every software system has to be bullet-proof, embedded systems often have to be quite robust. And it's a lot easier to make a system robust if you have a checklist of things to consider when designing and testing.

Fortunately, just such a checklist already exists. Roy Maxion and Bob Olszewski at Carnegie Mellon created a structured list of exceptional conditions to consider when designing a robust system in the form of a fishbone diagram.

(Source: Maxion & Olszewski, Improving Software Robustness with Dependability Cases, FTCS, June 1998.)
 

The way to read this diagram is that an exception failure could be caused by any of the general causes listed in the boxes at the end of the fish-bone segments, and the arrows into each fishbone are more specific examples of those types of problems.

If you don't have the picture handy, a way to remember the main branches is:

C - Computational problem
H - Hardware problem
I- I/O and file problem
L - Library function problem
D - Data input problem
R - Return value problem
E - External user/client problem (in embedded systems this may include control network exceptions)
N - Null pointer or memory problems

There isn't a silver bullet for exception handling -- getting it right takes attention to detail and careful work. But, this fishbone diagram does help developers avoid missing exception vulnerabilities. You can read more about the idea and the human subject experiments showing its effectiveness in the free on-line copy of their conference paper: Improving Software Robustness with Dependability Cases,

You can read more detail in the (non-free unless you have a subscription) journal paper:
Eliminating exception handling errors with dependability cases: a comparative, empirical study, IEEE Transactions on Software paper, Sept. 2000.  http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/32.877848

You can find more insights from Dr. Koopman on his blog.

EDGE CASE RESEARCH
100 43RD ST.
SUITE 208
PITTSBURGH, PA 15201

Copyright 2015, Edge Case Research, LLC. All rights reserved.